“Ethics” comes with baggage. In the old days, people would call ethics when someone was behaving badly. Physicians in particular were naturally defensive when they would hear “We’ve called ethics” because that translated into “You are behaving badly” or worse “You are unethical.”
Ethics is personal and when someone says, “We need help from ethics” it feels like hearing someone say, “Your morals are not good enough!” Ethics may be personal, but ethics consultation is professional. So how does one overcome this attitude on top of so much baggage from the past?
At Clarian, we’ve adopted a policy for ethics consultation. It describes what an ethics consultation is, namely a service meant to help patients, families and health care providers address ethical dilemmas. The goal of an ethics consultation is to promote and support sound ethical reasoning and thoughtful problem-solving in clinical practice.
Perhaps the most significant challenge to requesting an ethics consultation is the fear that asking for help will get someone in trouble. Intimidation and or reprisals (retaliation) for seeking help are inconsistent with Clarian’s core value of a community of trust and respect. Retaliation comes in many forms: cold shoulder, questioning judgment, changing an assignment, even yelling at someone. None of these responses, from anyone, is appropriate when an ethics consultation has been requested.
Clarian has an open access ethics consultation policy, meaning anyone involved in the care of a patient may request assistance from ethics. It takes a great deal of courage to seek help in a situation where you feel more than one choice may be right, and it is unclear what is best for a patient.
Lucia D. Wocial, PhD, RN
Clarian Health Nurse Ethicist
To be a registered nurse at Clarian, visit Registered Nursing Position Indiana.
Julie entered nursing as a second career in search of a way to give back to the community and as a personal path to fulfillment, after having lived the glamorous but somewhat empty life as a manager in a retail jewelry store.